Insurance for IP Litigation Costs

Insurance for IP Litigation Costs

If you own any intellectual property (IP) rights, are you concerned about your exposure to litigation, and how you will finance any legal action?  One way to address this concern is by means of an insurance policy.

There are two main types of IP litigation costs insurance available, depending on whether litigation has been threatened:

  • Before the Event (BTE) insurance; and,
  • After the Event (ATE) insurance.

BTE insurance provides cover in advance of litigation arising; like taking out car or property insurance before an accident occurs.  One benefit of BTE insurance for an IP rights holder is that it can act as a deterrent to potential infringers, as they may be less likely to start or continue to infringe if they know you have the financial means to pursue litigation.  Additionally, BTE insurance can provide reassurance to potential investors, and allow you to keep cash available for other uses, such as to invest in growing your business.  BTE insurance can also provide coverage for infringement of the rights of others.

Insurers will tailor policies to meet your requirements and can typically cover:

  • the costs associated with enforcing your rights against infringers;
  • the cost of defending yourself against allegations of infringement;
  • the payment of damages for infringement; and/or,
  • the loss of income if you lose your IP rights.

Generally, insurers will require you to obtain permission before incurring any litigation costs, and they may refuse to cover certain legal actions if your chances of success are less than 50 – 60% based on the opinion of appropriate legal counsel (e.g., a barrister).

Factors affecting premiums for BTE IP insurance policies can include:

  • geographical coverage required: single country (e.g., UK only) is typically the cheapest, with international or worldwide being the most expensive, especially if coverage extends to the USA;
  • the level of risk involved: some technology sectors are known to be highly competitive and litigious, and so premiums will tend to be higher;
  • the limit of coverage required: e.g., policies covering litigation in the UK Intellectual Property Enterprise Court (IPEC) only will have lower premiums due to the cap on costs recoverable in this court; and,
  • the excess amount payable by the insured: this can start at around £5000 for patents; however, if the perceived risk or limit required is high, or if US cover is needed, then it could be up to £250,000 or more.

ATE insurance provides some cover after litigation has been threatened or started, but policies will typically only cover your costs should you lose at trial.  As with BTE insurance, many insurers will require a prospect of success at trial of at least 50 – 60% based on the opinion of appropriate legal counsel before agreeing to provide cover.  Therefore, a key benefit of ATE insurance is that it can encourage opponents to be more agreeable and settle early, before getting to trial.

ATE premiums will be higher than BTE premiums, but many insurers can offer staged premiums (meaning if you settle early you will only pay a proportion of the full premium), or partly/fully deferred and contingent premiums (meaning you only pay the premium if you win at trial).  This can make the cost of ATE insurance more manageable in some cases.

IP insurance may not be appropriate for every IP rights owner, but it can provide value in certain cases.  For example, Mandy Haberman, inventor of the Anywayup® cup, was able to successfully enforce her IP rights in several different countries due to having IP insurance to help cover litigation costs.  By securing her monopoly in the marketplace, her own business was able to prosper.

We recommend considering IP litigation exposure as part of your regular business risk analysis and exploring whether IP insurance can help you manage any risks identified.  Should you require any assistance or advice, please contact me at christina.schiavone@wynne-jones.com.

Related News

Wynne-Jones IP supports Mental Health Awareness Week
news

Wynne-Jones IP supports Mental Health Awareness Week

Wynne- Jones IP are proud to support Mental Health Awareness Week which takes place from Monday 10th May to Sunday 16th May 2021.

The Coronavirus pandemic has created new global challenges with many people suffering from increased stress and anxiety. Wynne-Jones IP are making a real effort to ensure staff feel supported and making both physical and mental wellness a priority.

Two salesman, a start-up company and the greatest medical invention of all time
news

Two salesman, a start-up company and the greatest medical invention of all time

The history of the now commonplace device is a rich tapestry of scientific minds, a desire to explore the unknown and relieve human suffering, an architect, and a drunken dog. But it was two salesman and a start-up company that made the greatest medical invention of all time accessible to the masses and paved the way for vaccination programmes, like the one we see in the fight against Covid-19 today, to be rolled out in large scales.

Inventions that changed the world – SME edition
news

Inventions that changed the world – SME edition

Entrepreneurs and small businesses play a critical role in the economy and this year World Intellectual Property Day focus’ on how they can use intellectual property (IP) rights to build “stronger, more competitive and resilient businesses.”

Some of the world’s best-known inventions and brands are the products of inventors and entrepreneurs who were savvy enough to protect their ideas. This week, to mark World IP Day we’ll be looking at five of our favourites, beginning with Thomas Edison.

When brand development can be a warzone it's vital that every General has a battle plan
news

When brand development can be a warzone it's vital that every General has a battle plan

Every day, businesses across the globe invest significant sums of money in building brands and launching products that have shaky foundations. Often, entrepreneurs and business owners are unaware of the risks until they find shots are being fired at them. Large companies are often willing to take on the fight since they have the necessary resources, but for some small businesses with less resources it can be a fight for their life…

How do you send a caterpillar 100 feet in the air?
news

How do you send a caterpillar 100 feet in the air?

The case of Colin the Caterpillar -v- Cuthbert the Caterpillar has caught the media’s attention.  In case you have been cocooned away and missed it, on 15th April 2021, Marks and Spencer (M&S) launched high court proceedings in the UK against discount supermarket, Aldi, alleging trade mark infringement and passing off. 

The thing everyone wants to know now is whether the case has legs.

How a Mexican yam and a start-up company transformed the lives of women
news

How a Mexican yam and a start-up company transformed the lives of women

Russell Marker, Carl Djerassi and start-up company Syntax transformed the lives of women allowing for more freedom, choice and the progression of equal rights. Today, 70 years after its creation, the contraceptive pill is taken by more than 3.1 million women in the UK. 

US Inventor Declarations and Assignments
news

US Inventor Declarations and Assignments

After a patent application has been filed, the inventor may be required to sign and submit various forms.  What happens if this is several years into the patent process, and the inventor can no longer be reached to sign these forms?  And what can you do now to prevent any complications from arising?

UKIPO ending temporary fee changes on 31 March 2021
news

UKIPO ending temporary fee changes on 31 March 2021

The UK Intellectual Property Office (UK IPO) temporarily reduced or removed certain official fees associated with patents, trade marks and registered designs because of the disruption caused by the Coronavirus pandemic. However, the temporary fee changes are set to end on 31 March 2021.

aipex logo aipex logo aipex logo we offer Covid-19 testing for our staff